What Does Calling Abortion A Fundamental Human Right Mean
The R.H.A. sets out the laws purpose to secure for every pregnant woman a fundamental right to choose to carry the pregnancy to term, to give birth to a child, or to have an abortion. The law also says that the state shall not discriminate, deny or interfere with these rights in any other regulations.
This has raised concerns about how this fundamental right may be asserted in the future against hospitals, doctors and other medical professionals who object to abortion in conscience. An official with the New York State Catholic Conference said that the law foresees a time in New York when its a crime to be pro-life. New York State Right to Life, a state political party and lobbying group, argues that this language opens the door to restrict efforts by pro-lifersand prohibit any limits on abortion.
The R.H.A. does not contain any explicit provision requiring anyone to perform or provide abortions, but neither does it explicitly provide any exemption for conscientious objection by health care professionals regarding abortion.
In other words, it is not yet clear what precise legal effect the fundamental right language may have. The pro-life movement is concerned about how it might be used in the future to compel participation in making abortion available, but it is unclear how and if courts would interpret and apply a fundamental right to abortion beyond the existing text of the law.
Q: Is Abortion Still Legal In New York Even Though The Supreme Court Has Overturned Roe V Wade
A: Yes. New York legalized abortion in 1970, three years before the decision in Roe v. Wade.
When Democrats took control of the state Legislature in 2019, they codified the landmark decision into state law. They were concerned, at the time, about a potential reversal of Roe v. Wade from an increasingly conservative Supreme Court.
More Questions About Abortion Laws Speak With A New York Attorney
If you would like to know more about the laws governing abortion in New York, there are many attorneys in your area who may be able to help. A private family law attorney will be able to discuss the penalties for violating New York’s abortion laws and required procedures. Speak with a New York lawyer today to learn more.
Thank you for subscribing!
You May Like: Where To Buy New York City Pass
Where Patients Obtain Abortions
In 2017, there were 1,587 facilities providing abortion in the United States, representing a 5% decrease from the 1,671 facilities in 2014. Sixteen percent of facilities in 2017 were abortion clinics , 35% were nonspecialized clinics, 33% were hospitals and 16% were private physicians’ offices. Sixty percent of all abortions were provided at abortion clinics, 35% at nonspecialized clinics, 3% at hospitals and 1% at physicians’ offices.
There were 252 facilities providing abortion in New York in 2017, and 113 of those were clinics. These numbers represent a 19% increase in clinics from 2014, when there were 218 abortion-providing facilities overall, of which 95 were clinics.
In 2017, 89% of U.S. counties had no clinics providing abortions. Some 38% of reproductive-age women lived in those counties and would have had to travel elsewhere to obtain an abortion. Of patients who had an abortion in 2014, one-third had to travel more than 25 miles one way to reach a facility.
In 2017, some 39% of New York counties had no clinics that provided abortions, and 8% of New York women lived in those counties.
States Where Abortion Is Legal 2022
Many believe abortion should be legal in certain cases and it is the sole responsibility and decision of the parents to decide whether to keep the baby or not. They are totally against the taboo of incest and rape, thus giving the upper hand to the victims or anyone who wants to abort their offspring.
There are many states in America where abortion is legal and there will be no federal charges or actions against the ones partaking in such activities.
Also Check: Is The New York City Pass Worth It
Some Are Concerned That Removing Abortion From The Penal Code Will Affect Pregnant Women Who Are Assaulted
The act also amends the definition of homicide. Homicide is no longer defined to include abortion or causing the death of an unborn child when a female has been pregnant for 24 weeks or more. Abortion is also removed as a definition of homicide. The following part of the law was removed under the definition of homicide: an unborn child with which a female has been pregnant for more than twenty-four weeks. The law also removed homicide from being defined as abortion in the first degree or self-abortion in the first degree. This, in essence, moves abortion from the penal code to the health statutes in New York, CBS News explained.
Republicans who opposed the bill were concerned this might make it more difficult for pregnant women who lose their baby in an assault to press criminal charges. Democrats disputed this concern, CBS noted. Republicans have offered proposals for new legal penalties in cases where pregnant women are assaulted. Its not clear at this time what those proposals are or if they will pass.
It appears that under different New York laws, a homicidecan still be deemed if a baby is born alive and then later dies due to injuries inflicted on the mom while she was still pregnant, so that approach still remains. As noted, the situations are complicated and the effect this law change could have on punishments is a complex issue.
Also Check: Nyc To Cabo
Heres What You Need To Know About Abortion Access In New York
The Supreme Court ruled on Friday to overturn the constitutional right to abortion, following through on the draft opinion leaked last month.
The decision, a reversal of the nearly 50-year-old Roe v. Wade ruling that protected the right to abortion, allows states to decide their own abortion laws. Itâs expected that about half of the states in the U.S. will impose abortion bans, according to the Guttmacher Institute, a reproductive rights advocacy group. Thirteen states, including Texas, Oklahoma, and Missouri, have âtrigger lawsâ on the books that now will go into effect since this ruling, effectively banning abortion within 30 days.
At least tens of thousands of people are predicted to flock to places like New York and California, which are considered âhavensâ for abortion access.
Hereâs what you need to know.
What is the current law around abortion access in New York?
In New York, abortion is legal at up to 24 weeks of pregnancy and after 24 weeks if your health is at risk or your pregnancy will not survive.
What protections for abortion exist in New York?
In 2019, New York state expanded abortion rights through the Reproductive Health Act. Prior to this legislation, abortion was regulated in the stateâs criminal code and hadnât been updated in 50 years. No other medical procedure was regulated like a crime, according to the New York Civil Liberties Union.
What resources are there for people seeking abortions in New York?
What could come next?
You May Like: How Much Is Amtrak From New York To Florida
Intersections With Religion And Religious Figures
In 1990, John Cardinal O’Connor of New York suggested that, by supporting abortion rights, Catholic politicians risked ex-communication. Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi said that “There is no desire to fight with the cardinals or archbishops. But it has to be clear that we are elected officials, and we uphold the law, and we support public positions separate and apart from our Catholic faith.”
How Will I Feel Emotionally After The Abortion
It has been our experience that the majority of our patients feel relief after the procedure. Every patient is unique, however, and may experience different and varied emotions. We understand that abortion may be a difficult decision for some patients, and the entire Choices staff is dedicated to serve you with compassion and sensitivity.
Also Check: How Do I Sign Up For Unemployment In New York
Are There Any Free Abortion Clinics
Many states will provide free consultations and might give someone free abortion service depending on their financial and emergency state. Most abortion is not free, surgical procedures can be expensive and insurance can be the only savior for people looking for free or low-cost service. Some planned parenthood healthcare systems and clinics may provide free abortion pills but hard to go on with operation with zero cost.
How Long Does An Abortion Take
On the operating table, it can take up to 20 minutes for the completion of the surgery. The vacuum or evacuation process might be over in a minute or two, but other things come into play. Starting from cleaning, observing the vagina, inserting the tubes, and safely pulling out the pregnancy tissue.
In the case of taking pills, it can take 2 hours to 24 hours to flush out the pregnancy tissue from the body.
Don’t Miss: What To Do In New York In One Day
How Abortion Law In New York Will Change And How It Wont
- Save Story
Save this story for later.
- Save Story
Save this story for later.
In the late spring of 2016, Erika Christensen was thirty-one weeks pregnant, and found out that the baby she was carrying would be unable to survive outside the womb. Her doctor told her that he was incompatible with life. Christensen and her husband wanted a child desperatelythey called him Spartacus, because of how hard he seemed to be fightingbut she decided, immediately, to terminate the pregnancy: if the child was born, he would suffer, and would not live long she wanted to minimize his suffering to whatever extent she could.
Christensen lived in New York, a state where, since 2014, an estimated twenty-five to twenty-seven per cent of pregnancies end in abortion. Abortion was legalized in New York in 1970, three years before the Supreme Court decided Roe v. Wade. Abortion was a crime in most other states in New York, it became a crime with major exceptions. It is still regulated in the criminal code, and, Christensen learned, it is a crime in New York if an abortion is performed after a woman is twenty-four weeks pregnant, unless the mothers life is in immediate jeopardy. Even though the baby in her womb would not be able to live outside of it, she would have to go elsewhere to have an abortion.
When An Abortion Can Be Carried Out
Most abortions in England, Wales and Scotland are carried out before 24 weeks of pregnancy.
They can be carried out after 24 weeks in very limited circumstances for example, if the mothers life is at risk or the child would be born with a severe disability.
Most abortion services will ask to perform an ultrasound scan to work out how many weeks pregnant you are. The length of pregnancy is calculated from the first day of your last period.
Abortions are safer the earlier theyre carried out. Getting advice early on will give you more time to make a decision if youre unsure.
Dont Miss: Where Is The Wax Museum In New York
Prohibited Abortions In New York
New York doesn’t have as many barriers to terminating a pregnancy, like some other states. If you choose to have an abortion, you won’t have to get the consent of your partner or your parents if you’re 18. As well, there’s no “cooling off” period in New York.
After the First 24 Weeks, With Exceptions
Abortions are illegal if they’re performed after the first 24 weeks of pregnancy, unless the fetus isn’t viable or the abortion is necessary to protect the mother’s health. One of the justifications for this requirement is that it’s a balance between the safety of the mother and giving her time to consider an abortion. Arguably, a mother could be able to make the decision to have an abortion within the first 24 weeks of pregnancy. After that amount of time, nearly the end of the second trimester, the risk of harm to the mother increases greatly. New York repealed all penal code statutes for aborting a fetus and thus there are no criminal penalties for abortion.
Drugs and Medicine That Cause an Abortion
New York law previously made it illegal to administer or take drugs with the intent to cause a miscarriage, but this section of New York’s penal code has been repealed.
When Abortion Is Legal In New York
New Yorks law says abortion is legal if it is under one of these circumstances:
- The abortion occurs before the end of the 24th week of the pregnancy.
- The abortion is necessary to protect the patients life or health.
- There is an absence of fetal viability, or the ability for the fetus to survive outside the womb.
Further, New York took abortion out of the criminal code. The penal code laid out various criminal penalties for those who performed an illegal abortion, including doctors who performed one after the 24th week if the mothers life was not in danger.
The law leaves it up to the mothers health-care provider to use their reasonable and good faith professional judgment based on the facts of the patients case to determine when/if her life/health is in danger.
Another Supreme Court decision, Doe v. Bolton, says health refers to all factors physical, emotional, psychological, familial, and the womans age relevant to the well-being of the patient when it comes to an abortion.
Read Also: How To Become A Real Estate Broker New York
Landscape And Implications Of State Abortion Restrictions
Abortion is essential health care, critical to health equity, reproductive autonomy, and racial, gender, and economic justice it also helps ensure that people can control their own bodies, lives, and futures. The restrictions that some states are enacting disproportionately harm Black, Indigenous, and Latino individuals people with low incomes LGBTQ people young people people with disabilities immigrants and people in rural areas, for whom legal and systemic barriers frequently already put abortion care out of reach.4 Although some of the newly enacted state statutes described in this issue brief willlike Texas S.B. 8be challenged in court, there remains the looming threat that the governing law might change and that certain abortion-restrictive statutes that historically would have been found unconstitutional could take effect. This onslaught of restrictive state laws and the upcoming arguments in Dobbs v. Jackson Womens Health Organization are part of the anti-abortion movements efforts to legislate and litigate abortion access out of existence.5 Abortion rights are by no means secure throughout the United States.
New York Abortion Laws
Created by FindLaw’s team of legal writers and editors| Last updated July 12, 2022
In June 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court overruled Roe v. Wade in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which returned to the states the power to regulate, even prohibit abortion. New York abortion laws are less restrictive than those in many other states, which often impose long waiting periods, consent requirements, strict facility codes, and other statutory obstacles.
A bill signed into law in early 2019 added additional protections for abortion access, such as allowing certain medical professionals who aren’t doctors to perform the procedure and allowing abortions past 24 weeks if the fetus isn’t viable or to protect the mother’s health .
Also Check: How Much Is Minimum Wage In New York
Bans And Restrictions To Constrict Or Eliminate Abortion Access
Amid the COVID-19 pandemic, which presented the greatest public health threat in generations and exposed long-present systemic inequities in the U.S. healthcare system, legislators in nearly every state introduced bills that would undermine access to a form of essential health care: the ability to get a safe abortion. The Guttmacher Institute, which tracks state-level abortion legislation, has marked 2021 as the most devastating state legislative session for abortion rights in history.9 Guttmacher reports that as of early June 2021, 561 abortion restrictions have been introduced this year in all but three states.10 And as of early August, states had enacted 97 of those introduced abortion-restrictive statutes into law, bringing the total number of state abortion restrictions enacted since Roe v. Wade to 1,327.11
These newly enacted restrictions compound the harms of abortion-restrictive laws that preceded them. Of the 97 new measures, more than 80 were signed into law in states that already have onerous abortion restrictions, making abortion even harder to access. Mississippi, for example, whose 15-week ban is at the center of Dobbs v. Jackson Womens Health Organization, already has laws requiring a 24-hour waiting period and multiple trips to the clinic, a biased counseling requirement, and provisions targeting abortion providers.12 The states one remaining clinic is a party to the pending Supreme Court case.
Read Also: Submissions Poetry To The New Yorker
Q: Who Can Perform An Abortion In New York State
A: Abortions in New York can be performed by licensed physicians and some Advanced Practice Clinicians , including physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and licensed midwives.
If a pregnant person is uncomfortable talking to their doctor about getting an abortion, New York also has a family planning program that can guide individuals through their options.
A new state law, approved in June, shields abortion providers in New York from out-of-state civil or criminal legal action, including protection from extradition.
Providers are also protected from professional misconduct claims for offering abortion services, and medical malpractice insurance providers arent allowed to take action against them related to that work.
Read Also: Is There Any Beaches In New York
The Law Allows Health Care Practitioners To Perform Abortions But They Must Be Certified By The State
The law also has expanded to allow not just duly licensed physicians to perform the abortions. The act now says that an abortion can be performed by a health care practitioner licensed, certified, or authorized under Title Eight of the Education Law, acting within his or her lawful scope of practice NYCLU noted that the previous law didnt prevent other health care providers from performing abortions, but it did cause confusion about whether nurse practitioners, midwives, or physician assistants could provide abortions.
Sen. Liz Kreuger, D-Manhattan explained that all abortion providers still have to be certified by the state, Watertown Daily Times noted.