Brooklyn’s 5 Best Bakeries
Brooklyn has always been home to numerous great bakeries, with a few new ones poised to join the long-standing ranks. Whether you’re looking for a slice of homemade pie or a rendition of Ebinger’s famous Brooklyn Blackout Cake, here are a just a few of the borough’s best.
More: NYC’s 10 Best Sweets & Treats
2011 was definitely the year of pie in Brooklyn and Four & Twenty Blackbirds was the pie shop that started it all. Fresh pies are made throughout the day, with a rotating seasonal menu. Be sure to check out their Salted Caramel Apple or Black Bottom Oatmeal, or their newest flavor–and first cream pie–Banana Cream Pie.
Baked’s been in Red Hook for seven years now, and it’s still considered one of the best bakeries in Brooklyn. They specialize in making classic American desserts, extraordinary. Try their moist cakes and cupcakes, or go for a Brookster–it’s a combo of a decadent chocolate brownie made atop a chocolate chip cookie.
Greenpoint’s Peter Pan has been around since before the high-end doughnut shops came into town, and they’re still churning out some of the best. Thick cake doughnuts or fluffy yeast ones sit next to huge moist muffins, and black and white cookies. If you see a tray of fresh red velvet doughnuts making their way down the counter, be sure to snag one.
Siobhan Wallace is the co-founder of BlondieandBrownie.com.
First published on July 27, 2012 / 6:00 AM
Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop
727 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222-7026
If youre in the mood for a sweet treat, then Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop in Brooklyn is definitely worth checking out.
Having been open for over 60 years, Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop is a family owned and operated business that has a wide and very delicious variety of baked goods.
Hailed for their fresh donuts, some of the most popular flavors include:
- Red Velvet
- Sour Cream Glazed
- Apple Crumb
However, they dont just serve mouthwateringly sweet donuts. They also have a large variety of pastries, sandwiches, breakfast platters, bagels, rolls, flagels, croissants, and more.
In addition to their delicious baked goods, Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop serves an array of hot and cold beverages to accompany your food of choice.
If that wasnt enough to tempt you next time youre exploring the streets of Brooklyn, you should know that they have seasonal specials that vary depending on the season when you visit. Whether its winter, spring, summer or autumn, there is sure to be an option to suit everyone.
263 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211-4010
Established in 1972, they have multiple stores all over New York, with two located in Brooklyn.
All of the treats at Marthas Country Bakery are baked on-site, meaning that every time you visit youre hit with the delicious, comforting smell of freshly baked goods.
In addition to this, they serve cake pops, cheesecakes, pastries, puddings, pies, cookies, muffins, gelato and sorbet.
Experience Brooklyn Like A Local At These 10 Old School Neighborhood Italian Bakeries
When it comes to old school Italian bakeries in New York, Brooklyn takes the cake. For this list, we’ve narrowed it down from the two dozen-plus choices across the Big Apple’s most populous borough to a pastry-centric group of bakeries with that cozy neighborhood institution feel.
Each one is slightly different in terms of what’s popular, café or takeout only, and their surroundings. But they all have one thing in common: more often than not, the staff will know the customer by name along with what they tend to order.
Despite what some say, New Yorkers can be very friendly. But bakeries are like any other fast-paced service industry in the city that never sleeps. If there’s a long line, ask the person in front or behind you what to order instead of holding up the line with questions once it’s your turn. Follow that simple rule and you’ll be able to experience Brooklyn like a local at any or all of these old-school Italian bakeries.
Don’t Miss: How Much Is A Train Ride To New York
+ Best Bakeries In Brooklyn
In Brooklyn, Eat & Drink, Guides by Megan IJune 11, 2021
Bakeries in Brooklyn are no joke. From old-school generational Italian bakeries, French bakeries, fusion bakeries to little shops just selling sweet treats and delicious fresh baked bread, our borough is LOADED!
In fact, Brooklyn is a powerhouse for baked goods and bread. From sugar-filled treats to savory loaves of lard bread, the bakeries in Brooklyn are some of the most famous in the world. After all, this is where the famous Brooklyn Blackout Cake originated! This popular dessert combines layers of chocolate pudding, frosting, and cake crumbles to create a delicious dessert.
Brooklyn is also home to the famous Ebingers Bakery, which closed down in 1972. Although this is originally where the blackout cake came from, many bakeries in Brooklyn have followed in their footsteps and created their own recipes.
A fun fact about this bakery in Brooklyn, Ebingers created the Brooklyn Blackout Cake in recognition of the mandatory blackout drills to protect Navy Yard from enemy planes during World War II which employed over 40,000 workers.
Needless to say, the cake was popularized and stuck around even after the war.
Below are the 25 best bakeries in Brooklyn mixing in the old-school family-run mom and pop shops to the new kids in town shaking things up with their legendary treats and bread.
Best Bakeries In Williamsburg
You are zoomed out too far to see location pins. Please zoom back in.241 reviews60 reviews44 reviewsSite MapHow the site worksContact us
This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.more
Don’t Miss: What Channel Are The New York Yankees Playing On
Don Paco Lopez Panaderia
Don Paco Lopez Panaderia is a goldmine of Mexican sweet bread. The family business goes back 3 generations to the state of Puebla in Mexico, and has been one of the best bakeries in Brooklyn since 1991. They provide both the Mexican community and their multicultural neighbors alike with the homestyle flavor of Mexico.
Theres a multitude of options to choose from as far the pan dulce is concerned. If its your first time visiting I suggest the traditional and easily recognizable concha. At Don Pacos they bake it as good as anywhere youll find in NYC, making it airy and fluffy. It has a sweet, sugary topping that crumbles with every bite.
After you try the concha its all fair game. I suggest letting your inner child loose and grabbing anything that looks good. When I was growing up my parents would buy enough pan dulce to have with coffee over the next few days, and I encourage you do the same at this delicious Brooklyn Bakery.
Address: 4703 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220
Order Postmates In Brooklyn
The best Bakery – its out there, its probably nearby, you want it, and we have it. You want it delivered. We get it. Maybe, you want it in the morning, in the evening, or late at night when youre in the office on a rainy day. Satisfying your craving for Bakery does not have to be hard. We want to help, and that is why Postmates is always ready to get you Bakery at any time, when you want it, right at your door.
Also Check: Is It Legal To Smoke Weed In New York
The Best New Bakeries In Nyc
15 new bakeries with everything you could want after something goes wrong with your sourdough starter.
Theres a high probability that, at some point during quarantine, youve thought to yourself, I should probably try baking bread. But by now, perhaps youve realized that baking is hard to do, and even harder to do well. So here are 15 excellent new bakeries to try now that youve moved on from your intimate relationship with sourdough starter. They all have managed to open during the pandemic, offer takeout, and will make you reconsider spending the majority of your next stimulus check on a high-powered standing mixer.
Best Bakeries In Park Slope
You are zoomed out too far to see location pins. Please zoom back in.Site MapHow the site worksContact us
This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.more
Read Also: Where Is Broadway Theatre In New York
The Bagel Store 69 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217-4650
If you want to add a dash of color to a grey day in Brooklyn, then The Bagel Store is another fabulous bakery to check out. Known for their infamous rainbow bagels that took the internet by storm, this isnt a bakery or an eating experience that youre likely to forget about any time soon.
In fact, tourists travel far and wide to snap an Instagram of these aesthetically pleasing and equally as delicious bagels. Thats got to count for something, right? Not to mention, your kids will absolutely love them!
The Bagel Store allows you to choose from a variety of different bagels and different fillings. From savory fillings like cream cheese to their signature bacon, egg, & cheese bagel or sweet fillings such as their over the rainbow bagel with rainbow-fetti sprinkles cake-cream cheese or Nutella, the options are nearly endless!
The Bagel Store also offers a catering menu with some of their favorites, including the Original Rainbow Bagel Cotton Candy Bagel Platter and Coffee Joe to go. In addition to this, they also offer cold cut platters with a selection of delicious cold meats and cheeses.
Best Vegan Bakeries In Brooklyn
In Brooklyn, Eat & Drink, Guides by Guest AuthorJuly 19, 2021
Our guide to the best vegan bakeries in Brooklyn features a guest contributor, Sonia who is based in New York and has been on a plant-based diet for years and a completely vegan diet for over a decade.
For years, I worked slinging coffees, cakes, and sandwiches at a little café in Norman, Oklahoma. While we were considered a vegan friendly restaurant, all our cakes, pies and cookies were vegan always. I would get such a giggle out of customers who had a certain idea of what vegan was, and would stand there gob smacked- by the massive triple layer lavender cakes, stacks of cowgirl cookies, and massive trays of brownies.
They would sometimes ask, these are vegan? What are they made out of?. To which I would smile, and reply, Sugar, flour, and fat just like any other cake!
Vegan baking has come so far, even just in the decade I have been vegan. Many bakeries now carry at least one vegan cupcake option, and some more vegan-friendly or strictly vegan bakeries push the limits on what is available when youre struck by a sweet tooth attack.
Here are some of my top picks for the best vegan-friendly bakeries in Brooklyn. For more vegan meals around the city, check out the best vegan restaurants in NYC for more options!
Read Also: Is Ashworth College Accredited In New York
Best Bakeries In Nyc For Cakes
There comes a time when we all crave cakes and sugary treats. Preparing homemade cakes is very much possible because the most commonly required ingredients are flour, sugar, eggs, butter, baking soda, and a liquid.
However, sometimes preparing the cakes may not go as planned, and you may end up craving cakes done perfectly by professional chefs.
Nowadays, the preparation of cakes ranges and varies from simple to complex.
Well, New York has some of the best bakeries in the world. This is why you can readily get cakes in different forms.
New York is the best place to find delicious cakes whether you are looking for all-American cakes or French bakeries.
That said, there are several bakeries, particularly in Brooklyn, with delicious taste.
Here are some of the best places to go when you are craving cakes in NYC.
The 15 Best Bakeries In Brooklyn
Dave Fisher: Fresh flatbreads are second to none, as is the falafel sandwich – best in BK.
Ross Brown: The absolute best hummus in the world.
Youssof Mal: Awesome shop, full of freshly baked Arabic pastries and sweets, not to mention all the Middle-Eastern essential ingredients
Harlan Erskine: Nice brunch menu. The Lemon Ricotta pancakes were perfect! Their coffee is the one of the best for the area and they make everything in house.
Alexandra Fanning: These guys can do no wrong, coffee is perfect, croissants are amazing and the cakes look fantastic. People are super friendly – highly recommend
Valentin Guerin: Nice outdoor seating in the back
Alex Heath: Everything is vegan/vegetarian. Excellent cappuccino and nice place to hang out for awhile.
Kate H.: THE BEST vegan sandwiches I’ve found in Brooklyn so far. I’m not joking either.
Michele B.: Most amazing cinnamon rolls ever. They sell out early though. :, Brooklyn, NYBakery· Williamsburg · 6 tips and reviews
Kimmie Ohh: You can now get their famous walnut chocolate chip cookies in Brooklyn! Always warm & ooey-gooey!
Tiffany S: They now have a gluten-free chocolate chip walnut and its every bit as delicious as the original!
Christina Chin: Ooh they have two chip cookie! I hate nuts in my cookies so happy they offer one without that’s not double choc!
Larissa Alvarez: The black and white cupcake was dreamy. Excited to try more!
Jacqueline Huie: Cupcakes, cheesecake, cake, chocolate milk mmmmmm
for you
You May Like: How Much Is Hotel In New York City
The Best French Bakeries In Nyc
The past few years have been a renaissance for French pastry in New York. Not only are more shops serving better croissants, but ambitious upstarts like Dominique Ansel Bakery, Bien Cuit, and Lafayette have injected some much needed excitement into a pastry category that at times feels staid and dull.
This is great news for all kinds of pastry fansall this competition has boosted both quality and creativity. But it’s gotten near impossible to keep track of who makes the flakiest croissant, the softest brioche, and the crunchiest canele. And what if you’re craving something esoteric, like the perfect kouign aman or the most whimsical religieuse? That’s where this guide comes in.
Below you’ll find our recommendations for the finest French-style pastry shops in the city, with notes on what they do best. Not all of these bakeries are French specialists, but they do offer at least three destination-worthy French items.
Best Bakeries In Williamsburg New York City
Williamsburg has a longstanding reputation as a quaint and diverse neighborhood, with 18th-century architecture, charming brick row houses, and tree-lined streets. Alongside the historic homes, plenty of little shops and eateries give this place an old-world yet modern feel.
And if all these neighborhoods have anything in common with one another, its their love for food. Even if you live in Manhattan, you cant go wrong by spending a day in Williamsburg, wandering around quaint little shops and sampling the delights of local bakeries.
Here are 15 bakeries in Williamsburg that every person must visit before leaving the city.
Recommended Reading: How To Get A Social Security Card In New York
Stella Di Sicilia Bakery
217 Montrose Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, United States
Contact: +1 718-417-1849
Looking for the best place to eat in Williamsburg, look no further than Stella Di Sicilia Bakery. This lively bakery is located on Montrose Avenue, and its well known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere.
The kitchen staff is friendly, so you can enjoy your time while they prepare your meals to perfection. I love this place because its a go-to destination for Sunday brunch or special occasions.
This place has a wide variety of bread, pastries, and desserts. I love the Oreo pie and the cheesecake, but my friends prefer the apple pie and cheesecake.
This bakery is only an hour away from Manhattan and offers a great selection of baked goods to choose from.
The location is perfect for your daily errands in Williamsburg, and youll never be disappointed when you visit Stella Di Sicilia Bakery for your food needs.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Four & Twenty Blackbirds made pie cool again when it opened in 2009. We cant get enough of their smart, all-butter, vinegary-tangy pie crust thats as flaky as can be. But the ultimate treat is visiting the shop , where you can pick and choose from that days flavors. Actually, scratch that. Since you can buy by the slice, get all of them. The Salty Honey and Black-Bottom Oat are evergreen favoritesand any season fruit will be great.
Have you ever been to one of these bakeries? What are your favorite bakeries in Brooklyn? Share in the comments and tell us what to order!
Recommended Reading: How Much Is A Carton Of Cigarettes In New York
Doughnut Plant Downtown Brooklyn
245 Flatbush Ave Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11217-2457
Sticking in line with the doughnuts theme, you cant explore Brooklyn without paying a visit to Doughnut Planet. With seven stores to choose from in the whole of the city, you really cant go wrong with the beautifully buttery and soft doughnuts from this wonderful bakery.
Planet Doughnut has an array of mouth watering doughnuts, from standard doughnuts, to cake doughnuts, and sour doughnuts. Their classic doughnuts, such as their sprinkle mini yeast doughnuts and their vanilla bean doughnuts are crowd favorites.
However, they also have seasonal specials that they switch out that are super popular, such as their apple cardamom cake doughnut and their peach cake doughnut. For a really indulgent treat, why not try their filled squares doughnut?
Having dietary requirements doesnt automatically mean that you need to miss out on all of the fun, and Doughnut Planet recognizes this. As a result, they offer gluten-free and vegan doughnuts for people with allergies or those who follow a plant-based or vegan diet.
You can even order online and order ahead along with your morning cup of coffee if youd prefer not to wait in the queue!